47. Terry Glenn
When the Buckeyes lost star receiver Joey Galloway to graduation after the 1994 season, many fans fretted over who would fill his shoes. But when fleet-footed Terry Glenn emerged from relative obscurity, he stunned the nation with Ohio State’s greatest receiving season ever.

By the time the season was over, Glenn was named the winner of the Bilitnikoff Award, given to the nation’s best receiver. But just as he had seemingly come out of nowhere, he disappeared just as fast, to the NFL and professional football.